LISTEN TO THE EPISODE HERE:
In today's research roundup we cover four recent studies and help triathletes and other endurance athletes apply them in practice. We have ten years of training diaries from a World Championship medal-winning 800 to 1500 m swimmer, bicarbonate's effect on fatigued efforts in cycling, a fresh reanalysis of Hickson's famous 1977 "linear" VO2max study, and a meta-analysis of 69 trials on just how much time to do in HIIT sessions and continuous endurance sessions before running into diminishing returns.
HIGHLIGHTS AND KEY TOPICS:
- Ten years of training diaries and long interviews with a world-class 800 to 1500 m swimmer with 11 major championship medals: the volume, the intensity distribution, how the Norwegian group defines its zones, and what changed around the seasons when his results declined.
- Long-course against short-course pools for a short-course specialist, how much the turns were trained, and what that means for triathletes who will never do a turn in open water.
- Race-pace sessions that were never all-out, small regular doses of speed, and one heavy gym session a week: how a world-class distance swimmer built his specific preparation.
- Threshold sets from the paper's example weeks, with the splits and send-off times, and the case for longer rest between hard swim sets than most swim programmes give.
- Bicarbonate supplementation during three hours of riding, followed by a 2-minute and a 12-minute time trial: which effort changed, and the sodium question the design leaves open.
- Hickson's 1977 "linear increase in aerobic power" study reanalysed with modern statistics: whether the curve really was a straight line, how much faster the fastest responders improved than the slowest, and whether a programme this hard was the right one to study, where Daniel and Mikael see it differently.
- A meta-analysis of 69 randomised trials on HIIT and moderate-intensity continuous training: how many minutes per session it takes to get most of the VO2max gain, and who the answer actually applies to.
- Diminishing returns at three time scales, training for the athlete you will be tomorrow against the one you will be in five years, and how much intensity to give a brand new athlete.
Sponsored by:
Precision Fuel & Hydration
Precision Fuel & Hydration produce our favourite gels, sports drinks, and electrolyte and carbohydrate products here at That Triathlon Show and Scientific Triathlon. Use the free Fuel & Hydration Planner to get a personalised plan for your carbohydrate, sodium and fluid intake in your next event, and get 15% off your first 2026 order by using the code TTS2026 at checkout.
ROUVY
ROUVY is real routes cycling platform that let's you ride thousands of real-world courses with amazing graphics and feel! There are 75+ IRONMAN courses plus more than 20 Challenge Family courses to help you prepare for racing, and tons of other great features you'd expect from an indoor cycling platform like structured workouts, virtual races, and more. Go to rouvy.com and use the code TTS to get your first month for free on top of a 7-day free trial.
Effortless Swimming
Effortless Swimming create the best swim goggles on the market, that combine great fit for every face shape with a truly unique approach to preventing fogging. Instead of using an anti-fog coating, hydrophilic nanoparticles are permanently integrated into the lens, making them the only goggles that maintain their anti-fog properties for the long-term. Use the code TTS15 for 15 percent off, plus a free two-month Effortless Swimming course membership.
Shownotes
These shownotes have been generated using AI and have not been proofread in detail. They serve well to get an overview of the discussion, but for the full details and all the nuances, please refer to the podcast episode.
Ten years of training in a world-class distance swimmer
02:20 -
- The first study is "Ten years of training in a male world-class 800 to 1500 metre swimmer", an accepted manuscript (not yet formally published, but available on ResearchGate) by the Norwegian group of Espen Tønnessen, Øyvind Sandbakk, Thomas Haugen and colleagues.
- The swimmer has 11 individual medals at major championships (World and European), mostly in short course metre pools, though at least a couple came in long course. He has no Olympic medals.
- It follows the group's typical case study format: detailed, standardised training diary analysis combined with long-form qualitative interviews with the athlete and his two coaches, the club coach and the national team coach.
- The athlete and coaches were involved when the quantitative and qualitative data were analysed together, to make sure the conclusions did not misinterpret either the data or their feedback.
- Daniel says the format and style will be familiar to anyone who has read the Norwegian papers, and that this one is another good read.
- Mikael says long-term case studies like this might be his favourite type of study, even compared to randomised controlled trials or meta-analyses. They cannot support causal conclusions, but they generate hypotheses that researchers can test in controlled trials, and that coaches and athletes can test in practice.
Volume, long course metres and the turns
05:52 -
- The swimmer peaked between the ages of 22 and 24, the seasons before the pandemic, and set no new personal bests from around age 25. Mikael points out that this is fairly normal for swimmers, including 800 to 1500 m specialists.
- He trained about 1,000 hours a year at age 19, rising to close to 1,400 hours at 25. Around 80% was swimming. The rest was dryland work: flexibility (mostly before swimming), strength training, and some incline walking and running in certain seasons.
- A typical week was 60 to 65 km at age 19, increasing to 80 to 100 km in his mid-20s, for an annual total of 3,000 to 3,400 km in most seasons.
- The share of training done in long course metres rose from about 35% in the early years to around 60% in his best seasons, then dropped again, mainly because construction work at his pool made the logistics harder. That drop was one of the things that coincided with his decline.
- Daniel found it an interesting anomaly that long course volume increased while his best results came in short course competitions.
- Mikael's hypothesis, partly informed by his coaching experience, is that swim fitness benefits most from training in long course metres. The swimmer's short course strength may have come from a deliberate focus on executing every turn well in every session.
- Most of his heavy gym work was aimed at leg power for the turns (and starts), not upper body strength. His upper body gym work was mainly for injury prevention.
- Mikael's takeaway is that you get the fitness benefit in short course from training long course, as long as you also practise the turns, and at these distances you still get plenty of turns.
- Daniel adds that triathletes have no turns in open water, so long course metres is probably the best option for them.
Intensity distribution and controlled race-pace work
11:12 -
- Most of the training was below the first lactate threshold (LT1): about 84 to 93% of the distance swum, depending on the time of year and the season. Mikael's rounded summary is roughly 85% easy, 10% threshold and 5% higher intensity.
- There were no dedicated speed sessions. Speed work came in short sets, as part of warm-ups for threshold or race-specific sessions, or inside otherwise easy days. Small doses, done consistently.
- Lactate testing every six to eight weeks kept the zones up to date. Zone 1 was defined as 1.5 mmol/L or lower, or 72% of maximum heart rate or lower. Zone 2 ran from there up to LT1, so zone 2 in this paper is still below the first lactate threshold.
- Over the early years they gradually shifted easy training from zone 2 towards zone 1. That reversed somewhat in the later years, which also coincided with his poorer performances.
- Daniel was struck by the zone 1 pace of about 1:08 per 100 m, which together with the volume he finds very impressive.
- Mikael was somewhat surprised that the threshold and race-specific splits were not faster, based on what he has heard from other swimmers. He sees clear overlaps with the version of the Norwegian method Marius Bakken described on the show recently.
- Threshold sessions were very controlled, with fairly low lactate and effort but high accumulated volume, including double threshold days. Race-specific sessions were described as never exhaustive and never all out.
- Mikael thinks it is very common for athletes to do race-specific sessions faster than race pace, like a 5 km runner with a race pace of 3:00 per kilometre running their session at 2:55. This swimmer's 1500 m pace is 59 seconds per 100 m in long course and 58 in short course, but his race-pace sessions might progress from 1:02 down to 0:59.
- Daniel suggests that in swimming, stroke rate and technique play such a big part that staying close to race pace rather than ahead of it may matter more than in other sports.
- Mikael adds that because water is so dense, a small increase in speed brings a large increase in metabolic cost at higher paces, and a lactate test in the pool shows how much one or two seconds per 100 m can change.
Periodisation, strength and the later decline
19:26 -
- The proportion of front crawl increased from about 50% in the early years to 75% later on, with less of the other strokes, drills and pull. Since his best results came at 22 to 24 rather than in the later years, Mikael thinks there might be something to keeping some other strokes even for a front crawl specialist.
- Periodisation was fairly traditional, with three macrocycles a year. General preparation was high volume with a threshold focus, then volume dropped and some threshold sessions were replaced by race-specific work in zone 4 (between LT2 and maximal aerobic speed) and zone 5 (above maximal aerobic speed, but not all-out sprinting).
- Flexibility work was spread out as 15 to 20 minutes before every session, which adds up with 12 to 14 sessions a week.
- Mikael expected more strength training. The swimmer described one heavy session of about an hour per week as optimal, because more than that compromised his high-intensity swimming. Daniel says this fits the earlier paper on Norwegian views of strength training they discussed.
- Daniel highlights the very big sessions of more than 10 km, which the swimmer said gave him a lot of confidence.
- The worse seasons were linked to factors outside training. Moving out of his parents' home meant more stress and made it harder to keep a structure around sleep and diet.
- His training group also shrank, from many peers of a similar age at 19 to two or three much younger swimmers by 25, and his motivation and commitment to racing fell.
- Mikael asks what is the chicken and what is the egg: did he perform worse because of lower motivation, or lose motivation because he performed worse? Most likely it is a complex interaction between all of these factors.
- Daniel notes that the paper mentions monotony, and speculates that rushing through boring sessions could have pushed more of his training up into zone 2.
- Mikael recalls that the shift to more zone 2 and more race-specific work was intentional and came from the athlete, possibly after his performances had already started to decline. He sees this as a common trap for competitive athletes: when performance slides, the instinct is to do more or go harder.
Practical applications from the swimmer case study
26:06 -
- Most listeners are not world-class swimmers, but Mikael thinks the case study still helps in understanding the training process.
- The first, general application is that easy work should stay easy. For anyone from medium to high volume, Mikael believes most endurance training should be in zone 1 rather than zone 2. It may be different for a low-volume athlete.
- General preparation combined volume with threshold work on two or three days a week, sometimes double threshold. It is a strategy that seems to work for many athletes, though not necessarily for every amateur.
- Mikael's advice to any swimmer or triathlete is to swim long course if you can. Your times may look worse, but you will get fitter than in a short course pool.
- Race-pace sessions were never exhaustive, even for races lasting seven to eight minutes (800 m) and 14 to 15 minutes (1500 m). Speed work came in small, regular doses of around four to eight 10-second sprints, similar to strides in a run.
- On strength, Mikael flags possible confirmation bias, since this is a big swimmer at about 190 cm. He generally adds one upper body exercise per gym session for his athletes, but is sceptical that gym strength does anything for swimming performance.
- Factors outside training (living situation, sleep, diet, motivation and the training group) matter a great deal, echoing many past episodes on the value of a good training group.
- Daniel adds the big confidence-building sessions. He thinks many athletes settle into swimming certain distances, sometimes shorter than an Ironman swim, and that occasional long sessions could be valuable.
Example sessions and rest intervals
31:04 -
- The example sessions are in Table 3 of the paper, with weekly volumes, exact sessions, splits, send-off times, and whether each session was done in short or long course.
- In general preparation, an example week was 74 km, 23 hours and 12 sessions. Tuesday's main set was 8 x 400 m holding 4:20 (1:05 per 100 m), leaving on 5:30.
- Mikael does not find that threshold pace especially impressive. In the Norwegian approach it is about control, so the swimmer may be at around 2.0 mmol/L, where other swimmers might do threshold sets at 3.5 to 4 mmol/L.
- The 5:30 send-off gives about 1:10 of rest. Mikael sees many swim programmes with almost no rest between threshold repetitions, whereas other endurance sports use rest to allow more total work at higher quality.
- With only 15 seconds of rest after four to five minutes of threshold work, you fatigue faster and cannot hold even splits. Mikael thinks many swimmers should lengthen their rest in intensity sets, while rest in zone 1 and zone 2 work can stay short.
- In race-specific preparation, Tuesday afternoon was 20 x 100 m long course in 1:04 progressing to 1:01, leaving on 1:30, roughly a 2:1 work-to-rest ratio. That is still slower than his race pace of 58 to 59 seconds per 100 m.
- Saturday morning the same week was 12 x 200 m in 2:10 down to 2:00, progressing from threshold to zone 5, leaving on 3:00 to 4:00, which Mikael reads as reaching roughly a 1:1 work-to-rest ratio at the end.
- Daniel says the table gave him many ideas for new sessions and is worth looking up. Mikael thinks the overlap with triathlon is greatest for ambitious athletes swimming four or five times a week.
Bicarbonate gels and durability
36:38 -
- Daniel's first study is "Bicarbonate and Carbohydrate Co-Ingestion During Exercise in a Novel Gel Format Improves Time Trial Performance After Three Hours of Moderate Intensity Exercise", published in 2026 with Bernardo Norte as lead author.
- It falls into the durability area. The authors explain there is little research on supplements and durability beyond carbohydrate, which this group has also studied.
- Participants were 11 trained cyclists (eight men, three women) with a VO2max above 45 mL/kg/min, training about nine hours a week, and used to taking in 80 g of carbohydrate per hour in at least one session a week.
- The normal gel contained 40 g of carbohydrate. The bicarbonate gel contained 40 g of carbohydrate plus 5 g of bicarbonate.
- After fresh-state 2-minute and 12-minute time trials, the cyclists rode three hours at moderate intensity with seven gels. In the bicarbonate condition four of the seven were bicarbonate gels, about 20 g of bicarbonate in total. Then came a 2-minute time trial, a 15-minute break and a 12-minute time trial.
- In the 2-minute time trial, performance declined in both conditions, with no difference between them.
- In the 12-minute time trial, the decline was about 12 W less with bicarbonate, roughly 6%. The authors describe this as roughly halving the drop in performance from fresh to fatigued.
- There were no apparent GI problems, historically an issue with bicarbonate, and no preloading: bicarbonate was taken only during the moderate-intensity riding.
- Daniel thinks it suggests bicarbonate during a long effort can preserve performance at the end of a race, for example a cyclist approaching a final climb, though without a benefit for the shorter effort the exact use case is not yet clear.
Race use cases and the sodium question
41:04-
- Mikael finds it interesting that there was a difference at 12 minutes but not at 2 minutes. He would have expected buffering to matter over two minutes. In absolute watts the bicarbonate condition did decline less there too, but not significantly, and a bigger sample might show a difference, though he stresses that is speculation.
- He thinks cycling races are a strong use case, believes many cyclists already use bicarbonate for this reason, and notes it is also big in running. After the tight New York Marathon finish, he suggests it could plausibly help a fast final few kilometres.
- The natural next question for him is whether it helps something like the 10 km run off the bike in Olympic distance triathlon, and we do not know that yet. For running, gut comfort remains the challenge, though newer products are better.
- Daniel mentions previous work in which bicarbonate taken before a three-hour effort reduced the loss of power by about 3%, compared with about 6% here, suggesting the buffering benefit may matter more when fatigued. He sees a possible case for preloading and then topping up with gels, much as athletes do with caffeine.
- The gels were provided by MNSTRY, which makes plain, caffeine, bicarbonate, and caffeine plus bicarbonate versions. Participants could not be blinded because the bicarbonate gels have a distinct flavour.
- Daniel notes these products use encapsulation to reduce gut problems, similar to what Maurten claims. Whatever you use, try bicarbonate in training before a race.
- Mikael asks whether the control condition received sodium, since most supplemental bicarbonate is sodium bicarbonate. Daniel confirms it did not, and mentions reports of fewer cramps with a bicarbonate product, possibly due to the sodium dose.
- Mikael sees this as a limitation that makes it harder to separate any sodium effect. Sodium should not normally affect performance much, but in a durability test it potentially could, which future studies could look at.
- Overall Mikael sees it as a positive study that extends the potential use case for bicarbonate. Daniel would still look at carbohydrate first for durability, pointing to the same group's study showing a big difference between 120 g and 60 g per hour, with bicarbonate as a possible secondary factor.
Revisiting Hickson's 1977 study
49:03 -
- The third study is "Adaptive response heterogeneity induced by a strenuous program of endurance exercise: a reanalysis of Hickson et al. (1977)" by Arthur Bossi of Edinburgh Napier University, published in October 2026 in the Journal of Applied Physiology.
- The original paper, "Linear increase in aerobic power induced by a strenuous program of endurance exercise", is one of the most famous in sports science. It published individual participant data, rare in the 1970s, and tested VO2max every week for 10 weeks.
- Daniel thinks the programme would be impossible to convince anyone to do. The paper itself called it intolerable.
- The participants were active adults rather than endurance athletes, with an average baseline VO2max of 39 mL/kg/min. Mikael suspects untrained people may not know how to push themselves fully for 40 minutes, so they may have stayed somewhat below their true capacity.
- The programme had six sessions a week plus a weekly VO2max test. Cycling days were 6 x 5 minutes at the power that elicited VO2max, reset each week, with 2 minutes of recovery.
- Running days alternated with cycling and were self-paced, all-out time trials: 30 minutes in week one, 35 in week two, and 40 minutes from week three onwards.
- Relative VO2max rose on average from 39 to 55 mL/kg/min by week 10, a 44% improvement. By Mikael's conversion absolute VO2max rose 39%, so presumably some weight loss contributed.
- Asked whether they wanted to continue after 10 weeks, only one participant did, and stopped after about three more weeks.
Diminishing returns and individual differences
54:28 -
- Hickson and colleagues were surprised that VO2max was still increasing linearly at the end. Bossi reanalysed the data with modern statistical methods, comparing a linear model with curvilinear models, and tested whether individual rate parameters improved the fit.
- Daniel thinks it was a good idea to test the linear assumption, since VO2max cannot increase forever. He was surprised statistics had changed that much, and Mikael suggests it may be as much about resources: tools like R or even Excel make this easy today.
- The linear model did not fit best. Several curvilinear models fitted better, the best being quadratic, all showing diminishing returns: rapid improvement at first, then gradually slowing.
- At the start, the average weekly gain in VO2max was 154 mL/min. By week 10 it was 84 mL/min, 54% of the starting rate. Mikael notes that with 4 to 5 L/min a good absolute VO2max for many athletes, 154 mL/min per week is substantial.
- Including individual adaptation rates also improved the model, and the differences between individuals were larger than in previous studies.
- Bossi speculates this is because the programme was close to the maximum tolerable stimulus, which magnifies differences in adaptation rate, at least in the short term.
- The 95% range of individual rates ran from 63% to 137% of the average, so the fastest improvers gained roughly twice as fast as the slowest. Everyone improved: Mikael stresses there were no non-responders, just faster and slower ones.
No free lunch: what to take from Hickson and Bossi
1:00:12 -
- Mikael's take-home message is "no free lunch". Training hard can produce fast gains, but they slow down, and here they slowed substantially within 10 weeks, even with an extreme programme that he says he certainly could not do.
- It reminds him of the meta-analysis by Mølmen and colleagues he discussed with Gabriele Gallo: sprint interval, VO2max and low-intensity training can produce similar improvements, but over different time courses.
- Sprint interval training saturates in perhaps two to three weeks and high-intensity interval training in something like six to ten weeks, while low-intensity training keeps producing gains for months or years. Mikael adds he does not remember the exact numbers.
- High intensity cannot replace low-intensity work indefinitely because it saturates, which is where periodisation comes in.
- Daniel thinks six to eight weeks on a single high-intensity stimulus is probably enough before changing focus, given how much the rate of improvement had slowed by week 10.
- Mikael finds the reanalysis concept interesting in itself and wonders what other old datasets could be revisited. He stresses that Hickson was not wrong: it is still a legendary study, and the question is which of today's conclusions we will see differently in 50 years.
- Daniel would like future studies to use more practical interventions, perhaps longer with less load, though he calls it debatable. Mikael thinks it can be argued both ways, and that studies testing the limits of human adaptation are valuable even when they cannot easily be replicated in practice.
HIIT versus continuous training: the dose-response
1:05:45 -
- Daniel's second study is "Optimising Exercise Prescription: A Meta-Analysis Examining the Dose Response of Exercise Duration on Cardiorespiratory Fitness Following HIIT and MICT", published in September 2026, with Felipe Mattioni Maturana and Nur Hidayah Asilah Zadon as lead authors.
- It compared how session duration relates to improvements in cardiorespiratory fitness for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT), and whether this differed between healthy people and those with cardiovascular risk.
- Included studies were randomised controlled trials of at least four weeks, including both HIIT and MICT, without nutrition or strength components, and excluding people with cardiovascular disease.
- HIIT was defined as efforts above 85% of maximum heart rate or above 80% of VO2max, including longer and sprint intervals. MICT was defined as 50 to 80% of VO2max or 65 to 80% of maximum heart rate.
- Both changed VO2max by approximately 4 mL/kg/min. The per-session time to achieve 100% of the adaptation was about 23 minutes for HIIT and about 63 minutes for MICT.
- Daniel's reading of "100%" is that it comes from the modelled curves: the total time needed for the full adaptation, with the authors also showing the shorter durations needed for 80% and 50%.
- For HIIT the relationship was non-linear and flattened quickly, reaching a point where extra time brought no extra benefit. For MICT it was linear, so more time continued to bring benefit.
- Daniel's interpretation is that within a session you should aim for about 20 minutes of time at intensity to get the full HIIT benefit, after which returns diminish.
- The authors frame it for relatively untrained people with limited time, but say the two types of training are complementary and the durations are an indication from previous work rather than optimal values.
Time scales and training density
1:12:17 -
- Mikael connects the three studies: diminishing returns at the session level in the meta-analysis, over a 10-week block in Bossi's reanalysis, and over 10 years in the swimmer, who built up for at least four or five seasons at more than 3,000 km a year before his best results.
- For Mikael, the most important point of the episode is this: to optimise the athlete you will be tomorrow, you might be better off doing a high-intensity session. To optimise the athlete you will be next year or in five years, it is about finding the balance, and much of it comes down to consistent volume of low-intensity training.
- Daniel adds that it depends on time available. The swimmer trained around 30 hours a week, which is where the linear relationship for continuous training pays off, while athletes with less time may still optimise with intensity.
- Mikael raises the question of density. 10,000 hours over 10 years is 1,000 hours a year, a professional volume, while over 20 years it is 500 hours a year, fairly normal for an ambitious amateur triathlete.
- He would like to know how much the outcome differs between accumulating the same hours faster or slower. He thinks density matters to some extent, but that simply accumulating the hours gets you a long way.
- Daniel's view is that intensity creates density early, so the curve rises faster and then plateaus, and the extra volume of moderate-intensity work is needed to reach the eventual peak. A block of intense work might put a bend in the curve rather than produce two straight lines of different slopes.
New athletes and how little HIIT is enough
1:18:02 -
- Mikael thinks it depends on the athlete. A new athlete who is motivated to train hard can include some high-intensity work straight away, perhaps not on the run but on the bike and in the pool, if enjoying it makes them more consistent. He is not talking about a Hickson programme.
- An athlete who mainly wants fitness and health and does not enjoy pushing hard can do only easy training and build it up. Either route is fine, as long as it keeps them consistent and free of injury and overtraining.
- Daniel notes that the authors say continuity matters most for newer athletes, and suggest future research on whether different types of training suit different athlete profiles.
- Daniel thinks coaches are sometimes too conservative with new athletes, building a big base before adding much intensity, and sees this paper as support for including some intensity early.
- Mikael emphasises that for newer athletes you need very little work at high intensity to get good benefits. It does not have to be 5 x 5 minutes at VO2max.
- Daniel suggests sessions like 8 x 2 minutes or 5 x 3 minutes start to reach the range where the meta-analysis saw benefits, which he describes as 15 to 20 minutes at intensity.
- Mikael would be comfortable going significantly lower with beginners, for example 8 x 1 minute building to 10 x 1 and 12 x 1 minute. Taking the paper's 11-minute figure at face value, you get 80% of the benefit at that point.
- The sessions usually discussed, such as 4 x 5 minutes, 4 x 6 minutes or three sets of 13 x 30/15s, accumulate 20 minutes or more at VO2max. Mikael says that is typical in sports science but not necessarily optimal, and for newer athletes may be far more than needed to get roughly 80% of the gains.
LINKS, RESOURCES AND RELATED EPISODES
- Follow Daniel on his website, Substack and Instagram
- Related episodes:
- Studies discussed:
- Ten years of training in a male world-class 800-1500 m swimmer - Tønnessen et al. 2026
- Bicarbonate and Carbohydrate Co-Ingestion During Exercise in a Novel Gel Format Improves Time-Trial Performance After 3 h of Moderate-Intensity Exercise in Trained Cyclists - Norte et al. 2026
- Adaptive response heterogeneity induced by a strenuous program of endurance exercise: a reanalysis of Hickson et al. (1977) - Bossi 2026
- Linear increase in aerobic power induced by a strenuous program of endurance exercise - Hickson et al. 1977
- Optimising Exercise Prescription: A Meta-Analysis Examining the Dose Response of Exercise Duration on Cardiorespiratory Fitness Following HIIT and MICT - Mattioni Maturana et al. 2026



